Indigenous Ceremonial Stone Landscape Protection

For: A project of Creative Thought and Action
Sandisfield, MA
Organizer: Climate Action Now
Indigenous Ceremonial Stone Landscape Protection (A project of Creative Thought and Action)
$48,348
of $57,000 goal
84% Complete
Raised by 134 donors

The Story

Please note: the image is an example of a ceremonial stone feature, but this particular feature in the image is not in Sandisfield.

Climate Action Now is a grassroots community group. Creative Thought and Action is their fiscal sponsor and is a 501c3 organization, which means any donations made to this campaign are tax deductible. If you prefer to send a check, please make it out to 'Creative Thought and Action,' write 'CSL' in the memo line, and mail to Rene Theberge, 250 Shutesbury Rd. Amherst, MA 01002. All funds collected from this campaign exclusively support the protection of the ceremonial stone landscape.

The Campaign

Indigenous American Tribes along the east coast of North America used stones as part of their religious and cultural ceremonies, and some of them are now being destroyed for gas pipeline projects. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) is supposed to ensure these ceremonial stone landscapes are studied before it licenses projects, but doesn’t. Instead, FERC regularly violates the National Historic Preservation Act by delaying the review of these features until it is too late to avoid them. When the Narragansett Indian Tribal Historic Preservation Office (NITHPO) learned that one third of the 73 identified ceremonial stones in Sandisfield, Massachusetts would be taken apart, it decided to challenge FERC’s order. NITHPO now needs your help to bring the case to the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. Climate Action Now is supporting NITHPO’s efforts, and the focus of its campaign is to raise funds for legal expenses, such as an attorney and court fees. Please share this page with your network to help us raise awareness and funds.

What are Ceremonial Stone Landscapes?

A Ceremonial Stone Landscape is an area in which stones and other features have been consciously positioned by Indigenous Americans for variety of reasons, such as marking astronomical cycles, deaths, or other significant events. Tribes have different beliefs about the meaning of these stone features, and interact with them in a culturally appropriate manner.

Doug Harris, the Deputy Tribal Historic Preservation Officer for the Narragansett Indian Tribe, explains the traditional belief is that these stones are physical manifestations of prayers to Mother Earth, calling for balance and harmony in places where traumatic events took place. In essence, they are living prayers in stone, and should not be altered. According to Mr. Harris, when the stones are disassembled and reassembled, “Then what you have is an artistic replica of something that was spiritual. Once you remove the stones, the spiritual content is broken.”

For the past fifteen years, NITHPO has been working with other tribes and federal agencies to promote the significance of Ceremonial Stone Landscapes, and has been leading efforts to preserve them. For example, NITHPO advocated for the protection of stone features in Turners Falls from the impacts of an airport expansion project, and as a result, the site and a twenty-mile radius was determined eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places in December 2008. More recently, NITHPO has been working with FERC to preserve ceremonial stone landscapes that are located in or near the proposed routes of interstate gas pipelines. These efforts join a centuries-long line of positive actions to defend the prayers in stone.

The Connecticut Expansion Pipeline Project in Sandisfield, MA

The Connecticut Expansion Project is an $87 million pipeline proposed by Tennessee Gas Pipeline Company, a subsidiary of Kinder Morgan. The project includes three “loops” of new pipeline that will be constructed next to an existing pipeline, with approximately one mile in New York, four miles in Massachusetts, and eight miles in Connecticut. The loop in Sandisfield, Massachusetts goes through a portion of Otis State Forest, which was taken by Tennessee Gas Pipeline Company through eminent domain, even though the forest is protected under the State’s constitution.

Indigenous Americans have occupied the Sandisfield area for thousands of years. After the Europeans arrived, Indigenous people lived alongside colonists, and also married them in order to preserve the sacred landscapes. The stones remained, untouched, until now. In 2016 the pipeline route was surveyed by a team representing four federally recognized Tribes - the Narragansett, the Wampanoag of Gayhead-Aquinnah, the Pequot, and the Mohegan - and 73 ceremonial stone features were identified in Sandisfield. However, FERC had already approved the route and the pipeline company had already taken the land through eminent domain, so FERC decided that it was too late to avoid one-third of them. At that point NITHPO realized that the process required under the National Historic Preservation Act was not working as intended, and retained Anne Marie Garti, who led the successful fight to stop the Constitution Pipeline, as counsel.

The Legal Challenge

On April 9, 2017, NITHPO moved for party status in the FERC permitting process and opposed the start of construction a few days later. On May 10, 2017, NITHPO requested a rehearing of FERC’s order that authorized construction. FERC must issue a final order on the request for rehearing before NITHPO can petition a Court of Appeals to review the validity of FERC’s order. There is no set time for this to occur, as FERC is currently without a quorum and cannot issue orders until more Commissioners are seated. If the Senate confirms President Trump’s two nominees in July, and they sign a final order in August, then the soonest NITHPO could file a petition for review is late summer or early fall.

The goals of this appellate review are to clarify and enforce federal law, namely the National Historic Preservation Act, FERC’s consultation requirements, and FERC’s fiduciary duty to Tribal Nations. While NITHPO cannot reveal its legal strategy to others, its motion to intervene and request for rehearing explain the legal issues in detail. (Links are provided below.) The U.S. Court of Appeals will issue an order that will be binding on FERC after reading the parties’ briefs and questioning their counsel in oral arguments. If NITHPO prevails on some or all of its claims, then FERC will have to comply with the court’s holdings in future pipeline projects.

NITHPO’s legal papers are available online.

NITHPO’s Motion to Intervene:
https://elibrary.ferc.gov/idmws/file_list.asp?accession_num=20170410-5037

NITHPO’s Request for one-day extension:

http://elibrary.FERC.gov/idmws/file_list.asp?accession_num=20170410-5040

NITHPO’s Answer in Opposition to the Requests for a Notice to Proceed with Construction

http://elibrary.ferc.gov/idmws/file_list.asp?accession_num=20170412-5079

NITHPO’s Request for Rehearing

http://elibrary.FERC.gov/idmws/file_list.asp?accession_num=20170510-5019

The ongoing threat from pipelines & FERC

Gas and oil pipelines are being proposed and built across the United States. Strict enforcement of the National Historic Preservation Act is needed to ensure the protection of our historic and cultural resources, including those that are significant to Indigenous American Tribes.

Visit our Facebook page for articles, resources, and
info about upcoming events! And/or signup for our mailing list.

Fundraiser Updates

Posted on March 28, 2018

Posted on March 28, 2018

On March 2, 2018, NITHPO started the legal proceedings by filing a petition in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. NITHPO is asking the D.C. Circuit to review two orders of the Federal Energy Regulatory System (FERC):

  1. April 12, 2017 order granting the Tennessee Gas Pipeline the right to construct the Connecticut Expansion Project and
  2. January 10, 2018 order rejecting NITHPO's request for rehearing.

FERC also denied NITHPO’s motion to intervene, forcing NITHPO to file a second request for rehearing. These procedural complications indicate that FERC is trying to keep NITHPO out of court.


Posted on January 15, 2018

Posted on January 15, 2018

Anne Marie Garti, NITHPO's lawyer, expected FERC to deny NITHPO's request for rehearing of the April 12th, 2017 notice to proceed with the construction of the CT Expansion Pipeline, and that is what FERC did on January 10, 2018.  You can view FERC's order here:
https://elibrary.ferc.gov/idmws/file_list.asp?accession_num=20180110-3068

The next step will be to petition for review of FERC's orders in the appropriate U.S. circuit court of appeals.

We are about $20,000 away from our $55,000 fundraising goal, which will be used to cover the legal expenses in NITHPO's challenge against FERC. If you haven't already, please consider donating on the YouCaring page and sharing this with your community. Thank you!

Posted on July 25, 2017

Posted on July 25, 2017

As of July 2017, the Ceremonial Stone Features under threat in Sandisfield, MA have been destroyed. While harm has been done in Sandisfield, desecration of ceremonial stone landscapes in the future can be legally avoided. "This is an opportunity to support the Indigenous peoples of our region so they can challenge FERC's behavior in the courts,” said Susan Theberge of the community coalition formed around NITHPO’s effort. “If successful, ceremonial stone landscapes will be preserved, not destroyed, a result that would have national implications.”

Challenging FERC in the courts will be a long and costly endeavor. To support this effort, a fundraising event will be held on Saturday, August 5, from 3-5pm at the First Churches, 129 Main Street, Northampton, MA. The event features a presentation on the significance of Ceremonial Stone Landscapes by Doug Harris, the Deputy Tribal Historic Preservation Officer for NITHPO. This event will be supplemented by cultural musical performances. For more information about the event click here.

About the Organizer

Report Fundraiser

Report Fundraiser

*Please report fraud and Terms of Service violations only. Personal disputes will not be reviewed.

* YouCaring will not use or share your phone number or other information for marketing purposes.

Comments

Supporters

Grab Our Widget

Indigenous Ceremonial Stone Landscape Protection

Grab Our Widget
Donate NowFacebook Share Button